ON THE HEALTH IMPLICATIONS OF THE POVERTY OF TRUTH
Abstract
Every epistemology, nay theory of Knowledge must give a befitting account of truth as against falsehood, error or lies. Thus, truth is concerned with questions such as: what it is to be the truth? Can one ever be sure that one has discovered the truth? Can we ever have reasonable assurance that we have the truth? What are the necessary and sufficient conditions of a statement being true? An inquiry for truth is a request for information either about what is said when something is asserted as true or about the condition under which it might rightly be so asserted. Issues and more like the above have created the problems of definition of truth, how to be certain about truth and how to know the truth, which in this essay I have chosen to refer to as the poverty of truth. In this essay, using the methods of philosophical exposition and analysis, I argued that truth is never definable, knowable and certain, and that these (which I have chosen to understand as the poverty of truth) have serious implications in matters of health.
Keywords: Epistemology; health; truth; post-truth; logic; probability; certainty
Metadata Record
References 27
- AJA, E. (2016) Elements of Theory of Knowledge, Nigeria: Auto -Century Publishers.
- Buffacchi, Vittorio(2021), Truth, Lies and Tweets: A Consensus Theory of Post-Truth.Philosophy and Social Criticism 2021, Vol. 47 (3) 347 – 361
- Brightman, Edgar S. (1925) Introduction to Philosophy , New York Henry Holt and Company.
- Blanshard, Brand (2001) “Coherence as the Nature of Truth” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Blanchard, Brand (1941) The Nature of Thought. London: George Allen and Unwin, Ltd.
- Copi, I.M. and Cohen, Carl (2001), Introduction to Logic . New Delhi, India: Prentice-Hall of India Private Limited, 9 th edition.
- Copi, I.M. (1972), Introduction to Logic. London: Collier and Macmillan Limited, 4th edition.
- D‟Agostini, Franca (2019) “Misunderstandings About Truth” in Church, Communication and Culture Vol. 4, 2019 – Issue # Special Issue on Post - Truth 266-286.
- David, Marian (2001) “Truth as Identity and Truth as Co rrespondence” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Davidson, Donald (2001) “The Foll y of Trying to Define Truth” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Devitt, Michael (2 001) “The Metaphysics of Truth” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- EBOH, B.O.(2017 ) Basic Issues in Theory of Knowledge, Nsukka: Fulladu Publishing Company.
- Feder, Judith (2003) “Why Truth Matters: Research Versus Propaganda in the Policy Debate” in Health Services Research 2003 June 38(3) 783 - 787 USA: Chicago, Hospital Research and Education Trust
- HAMLYN, D.W. (1970) The Theory of Knowledge, London: The Macmillan Press.
- Hornsby, Jennifer (2001)Truth: “The Identity Theory” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Jackson, Jennifer (1991) “Telling the Truth” in Journal of Medical Ethics 1991, 17, 5-9 March 1, 1991 10.1136/jme 17.15 (http://jme.bm.com)
- James, William (1975) “Pragmatism Conception of Truth” in Alburey Castell edited Essays in Pragmatism. New York: Hafeur.
- Kant, Immanuel: Critique of Pure Reason (A 805-806/B 833-834.).
- Klimck, Markus (2020) “Scientific Truths in Modern Times” in Colombian Journal of Anesthesio logy April -June 2020 Vol 48 Issue 2 Pp.59 60
- Leith, Sam. 2017. “Nothing Like the Truth.” Times Literary Supplement, August 16, 2017.
- Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Ma ssachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Lynch, Michael P. (2001) A Functionalist Theory of Truth Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Popkin, Richard H. and Stroll, Avrum (1993) Philosophy Made Simple, second edition. New York: Broadway Books.
- Putnam, Hilary (2001) “The Face of Cognition” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Russel, Bethrand (2001) “Truth and Falsehood” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.
- Sahakian, S. Williams and Sahakian, abel Lewis (1970) Realms of Philosophy. Philippines: Schenkman Publishing Company, Incorporated.
- Walker, Ralph C. S.(2001) “The C oherence Theory” in Lynch, Michael P. (edited) (2001) The Nature of Truth Classic and Contemporary Perspectives A Bradford Book, Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England: The Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) Press.