UNDER THE SPECTRE OF INSECURITY MAKING SENSE OF THE FORMATION OF PAKISTAN’S NATIONAL NARRATIVE: A REALIST PERSPECTIVE
Abstract
Narratives are an important part of nation-building. National narratives not only inculcate a sense of self; they also address a nation’s sense of security as well as insecurities. National narratives are an outcome of a nation’s collective historical experience and the ideas on which it is built. States facing security challenges and situated among or in a hostile neighbourhood, use their national narrative to achieve alignment both internally and externally. Pakistan’s national narrative is a testament of it. Since 1947, it has been facing threats to its national security. Pakistan’s national or meta-narrative addresses all such concerns. This paper focuses on the formation of Pakistan’s national narrative and the factors involved in its formation. Grounded in the Realism school of international relations theory, the paper overviews and critically analyses Pakistan’s national narrative and its contributing factors. This is followed by the development of a “structural–ideational framework” to make sense of the process of the formation of Pakistan’s national narrative.
Keywords: Pakistan; Narrative; IR Theory; Realism; Instrumentalism
Metadata Record
References 71
- Fore detail on this point see; Kenneth Waltz, “Man, the State and War: A Theoretical Analysis,” (New York: Columbia University Press: 2001)
- E. H. Carr, “The Twenty Years’ Crisis 1919–1939: An Introduction to the Study of International Relations,” (New York: Palgrave, 1939) p 109
- Fore detail on this please refer to: James Farwell, “Persuasion and Power: The Art of Strategic Communication,” (Washington D.C: Georgetown University Press, 2012)
- Mona Baker, “Translation and Conflict: A Narrative Account” (London: Routledge: 2006) p 19
- Margaret Somers & Gloria Gibson, “Reclaiming the Epistemological Other” Narrative and the Social Construction of Identity” in Craig Calhoun (Ed.) Social Theory and the Politics of Identity, (Cambridge: Blackwell: 1994) pp 37-99
- For further information on this, please refer to Catherine Riessman, “Narrative Analysis” (California: Sage Publications: 1993)
- Somers & Gibson,(1994) p 38
- Hassan Askari Rizvi, "Different Narratives of Pakistan," Daily Dawn, 14 August 2013
- Yaacov Yadgar, "From the Particularistic to the Universalistic: National Narratives in Israel’s Mainstream Press, 1967–97," Nations and Nationalism, Vol. 8, No. 1, 2002, pp 58-59
- For more on this point please see Jonathan Sacks, “The Home We Build Together: Recreating Society,” (London: Continuum, 2009)
- Laurie Brand, “Official Stories: Politics and Narratives in Egypt and Algeria,” ( Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2014)
- C Wright Mills, “The Power Elite,” (___________: OUP, 1956) pp 4-5
- Carr, E. H., “The Twenty Years’ Crisis 1919–1939: An Introduction to the Study of International Relations” (New York: Palgrave, 1939)
- H. J. Morgenthau, “Politics Among Nations: The Struggle for Power and Peace,” (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1948)
- A.Z. Hilali, “Cold War Politics of Super Powers in South Asia,” The Dialogue Quarterly, Vol. 1, No. 2. January 2006, pp 68-108
- “Daily Nawa-e-Waqat,” 7 July 1948
- Steven Brocklehurst, “Partition of India: 'They would have slaughtered us,” BBC Scotland news website, 12 August 2017. Available at: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-40874496
- “Bharatis raid East Pakistan Police Outpost,” Daily Morning News, 3 May 1950
- “Population Census Report 1951,” (Karachi: Pakistan Census Organization, 1951)
- “Pakistan Times,” 9 July 1948
- Mussarat Jabeen, “Language Controversy and its Impact on Politics of Pakistan,” South Asian Studies, Vol. 25, No.1, June 2010, pp 99-124
- Muhammad Ali Jinnah, “Address to a Public Gathering in Dacca,” M. A. Jinnah: Speeches as GG, Government of Pakistan,
- “The Referendum in NWFP 1947: A Documentary Record,” National Documentation Center Islamabad, 1996
- Pyarelal Nayyar, “Mahatama Gandhi, The Last Phase,” Vol. 2, (Ahmedabad: _____, 1958) p 170. Also see: Chaudhri Muhammad Ali, “The Emergence of Pakistan,” (Lahore: The Research Society of Pakistan, 1967) p 164
- Zahid Chaudhri, “Pakistan Ki Siyasi Tareekh: Afghanistan Ka Tareekhi Pas Manzar wa Pashtun Masla Khudmukhtari Ka Aaghaz,” Vol. 8 (Lahore: Idara Mutaalia Tareekh, 2013) pp 87-89
- Rizwan Zeb, "Pakistan and Afghanistan, 2014 and Beyond: Not Friends, Not Yet Enemies?," Journal of South Asian Development, , vol. 8(2), pages 165-183, August 2013. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0973174113494599
- “The Pakistan Times,” 25 June 1947
- “Daily Inqilab,” 29 May 1948
- “Daily Amroz,” 18 June 1948
- “Daily Nawa-e-Waqat,” 23 July 1948
- “Daily Nawa-e-Waqat,” 1 April 1949
- Fazalur Rehman, “Address to inauguration ceremony of Islamia College, Karachi, 25 July 1948 as quoted by “Daily Nawa-e-Waqat,” 28 July 1948
- Dr Umar Hayat Malik, “Press Conference on University’s Biennial Performance,” as reported in “Daily Nawa-e-Waqat,” 19 October 1949
- Moulvi Tamizuddin Khan’s presidential address to All Pakistan Political Science Conference in Lahore on 5 March 1947 as reported in “Daily Morning News,” 7 March, 1950
- “Ideal constitution for Pakistan: APPSC body drafts preamble & principles,” Dawn, 26 September 1950
- This point has aptly been discussed by Ambassador Shahid Amin. For detail see; Shahid Amin, “Pakistan's Foreign Policy: A Reappraisal,” (Karachi: Oxford University Press, 2010)
- For details see Muhammad Ali Jinnah’s interview with the Daily Times in “London Times,” 22 May 1947
- Margaret Bourke White, “Halfway to Freedom: in the Words and Pictures of Margaret Bourke White,” (Bombay: Asia Publishing House, 1949), p 92
- “Daily Nawa-e-Waqat,” 10 June 1949
- “Daily The Eastern Times,” Lahore, 18 September 1947
- “Islamic World Association of Pakistan formed at Lahore reception to Cairo Editors,” Dawn, 23 November 1947
- Leonard Binder, “Religion and Politics,” (California: UCP, 1963) p 196
- “Opening address at the First Education conference,” Dawn, 29 November 1947
- “Educationist Confer,” Dawn, 29 November 1947
- For detail on this point see, Zahid Choudhry, “Pakistan ki Siyasi Tareekh,” Vol. 11 (Lahore: Idara Muta’lia Tareekh: 1997)
- Dr. Muhammad Azam Khan, “Pakistan ke Pachas Saal: Aini aur Siyasi Irtiqa,” (Karachi: Qamar Kitab Ghar, 1997) pp 33-34
- “Recast of History and Geography Syllabus,” Daily Morning News, Dacca, 10 February 1950
- “Baitul Maal fund to be set up in East Pakistan: Question under consideration,” Daily Morning News, 7 June 1950
- Federal Minister for Commerce and Economic Affairs, Mr Fazalur Rehman was the president of the Pakistan Historical Society. Then Governor General of Pakistan Khawaja Nazimuddin inaugurated its first conference.
- Pakistan History board, in 1955, comprised of Mahmud Hussain, Minister for Kashmir Affairs, Dr. I. H. Qureshi, A. B. A Halim (VC Karachi University), Dr. A. Haleem (Professor of history at Dacca University); M.B. Ahmed (a civil servant) and Dr. S. Moeen-ul-Haq.
- Contributors to this publication included Dr. A. Haleem, Dr. Ahmed Hassan Dani, S. M. Jaffar, Riazul Islam, Dr. S. Moeen-ul-Haq, M.H. Siddiqi, S. M. Ikram, and R.E.M. Wheeler.
- For details on this point see: K.K. Aziz, “The Making of Pakistan: A Study in Nationalism” (Lahore: Izhar Sons: 1967)
- “Daily Nawa-e-Waqt,” 7 & 18 January 1956
- S. M. Sharif, “Report of the Commission on National Education,” Ministry of Education, Government of Pakistan Jan-August 1959” (Karachi: Manager of Publications: 1960)
- Aminah Mohammad Arif, “Textbooks, Nationalism and History Writing in India and Pakistan” in Veronique Benei, ed., Manufacturing Citizenship: Education and Nationalism in Europe, South Asia and China, (London: Routlege: 2005)
- Government of West Pakistan, “West Pakistan Textbook Ordinance XLI of 1962” https://pctb.Punjab.gov.pk/system/files/THE%20PUNJAB%20TEXT-BOOK%20BOARD%20ORDINANCE,%201962.pdf
- Indira Gandhi, “Speech at Lok Sabha on 16 December 1971” quoted in Safir A. Siddiqui, ‘Obscene Barrier: Another View’ in ‘Daily Dawn’ (Karachi, March 24, 2011) & Sultan M. Hali, ‘Bleakest Day in Pakistan’s History’ in ‘Daily Pakistan Observer’ (Islamabad: December 16, 2016)
- Syed Mujawar Hussain Shah, “Bhutto, Zia and Islam” reprod. Sani Hussain Panhwar (Online: n.d.) 96: bhutto.org/Acrobat/Bhutto_Zia_and_Islam.pdf
- Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto’s Statement in Daily Dawn, 16 April 1972
- Air Cdre. Sattar Alvi, "50 years on: Memories of the 1973 Arab-Israeli Conflict" The Express Tribune, 19 March 2015; https://tribune.com.pk/story/855837/50-years-on-memories-of-the-1973-arab-israeli-conflict/ ; also see Mushahid Hussain, "How Pakistan Views Israel and the Palestinians" in Middle East International, (September 1988) p 21
- For further detail on this please refer to Abdul Sattar, "Pakistan's Foreign Policy: 1947 to 2009 A Concise History”; (Karachi: Oxford University Press, 2010)
- Ahmed Rashid, “Descent into Choas: The US and the disaster in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Central Asia,” (Penguin Books, 2009) p 174
- Kamal Matinuddin, “Power Struggle in Hindokush (1978-91)”; (Lahore: Wajid Ali's; 1991)
- Rizwan Zeb, “Roots of resentment – II,” The Friday Times, 05 August <http://www.thefridaytimes.com/tft/roots-of-resentment-ii/>
- Article 227, Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973
- International Crisis Group, “Pakistan: Madrasas, Extremism and the Military”; (Islamabad: International Crisis Group Asia, 2002), as amended on 15 July 2005
- “Daily Nawa-e-Waqt,” 23 January 1976
- Act No. X of 1976, in ‘Extraordinary Gazette of Pakistan’ (Islamabad: April 3, 1976)
- National Education Policy, 1979
- Federal Ministry of Education Notification No F 11-16-81HST dated November 2, 1981
- University Grants Commission’s Directive as quoted in Azhar Hamid, et al., “Mutalia-e-Pakistan”; (Islamabad: Allama Iqbal Open University, 1983) xi